Hurt In Sheboygan? Don't Settle For Less Than You Deserve.
We've recovered millions for injured Wisconsin clients in car accidents, truck crashes, medical malpractice, and slip-and-fall cases. While insurance companies fight to pay you as little as possible, we fight to get you the full value of your claim, or you pay nothing.
- 25+ years fighting insurance companies for injury victims
- Millions of dollars recovered. See verified case results below
- $0 out of pocket. You pay nothing unless we win your case
Free Case Review
Tell us about your case. A real attorney will respond within 1 business hour.
See What Real Clients Say About Working With Us
Every review below is a real Google review from a real client. Click through to verify.
It's been great working with Toby. He's an excellent attorney that helped immensely during this difficult and stressful period. I especially appreciate open honest dialogue which he always provides.
Great experience overall! Very communicative & informed me about everything every step of the way!
I was in a life-threatening car accident in April of 2023 caused by a drunk driver. I was given Toby Mulholland's information through my insurance agent, and contacting him was the BEST decision I could have possibly made. Let me just say, Toby was my advocate every step of the way - in the midst of such a traumatic accident, I had comfort knowing my Lawyer was doing everything in his power to right the wrongs of the person who nearly took my life. Everything about that experience was new to me - I had never been in an accident, dealt with insurance, filed a suit, given a deposition, etc. Toby was informative regarding all the legal processes which were taking place, and answered all questions I had - in essence: he was my biggest advocate other than myself. He is extremely organized, well spoken, and knows exactly what he is talking about. Without his help, I don't know how I would have gotten through such a turbulent time. If you find yourself in a similar position to me, where it feels like your world is collapsing, medical facilities trying to push you around, insurance companies calling you... Toby Mulholland is the person you need to shield you from the noise, the advocate you deserve, and the best Lawyer around. Thank you for everything you have done to help me in my most dire of times, Toby!
Thank You for being more than attorney and seeing My situation for more than a payout if You're looking for a Lawyer that's gonna use the law to get You what You deserve and not be bought out by big corporations make sure You give Toby a call
I have been dealing with this law firm & Mr. Toby for a while now & have brought some friends to them, everyone left satisfied, and the relationship became more than just a client but a friendship, he works with passion, explains all the steps to you & guides you to the best, five stars ⭐️
Very responsible and caring team. I recommend Mulholland law to anyone in search of a great attorney. Toby was great! he is so down to earth and easy to reach. He clarified any doubt I had and explained the whole process step by step. Thank you so much for all you've done for me and my family. I am forever grateful!
Toby P. Mulholland: 25 Years Fighting For Injury Victims
A Quarter-Century Of Standing Up To Insurance Companies
Since launching his practice in 2000, Toby P. Mulholland has dedicated his career to representing people seriously hurt by someone else's negligence, and only those people. He doesn't represent insurance companies. He doesn't represent corporations. He represents the injured.
Toby has handled hundreds of cases spanning motor vehicle accidents, wrongful death, construction accidents, premises liability, dog bite, and catastrophic injury litigation. His career is marked by trial experience: numerous jury trials, mediations, arbitrations, and depositions, plus a reputation in Wisconsin, Illinois, and Arizona legal circles for innovative deposition strategies that move stubborn cases.
Clients consistently mention one thing in their reviews: he picks up the phone.
Real Cases. Real Verdicts. Real Money Recovered.
Past results don't guarantee future outcomes, but they do show what we're capable of. Below are recent recoveries for Sheboygan-area clients.
Client sustained multiple serious injuries in a motor vehicle collision. Recovery included compensation for extensive medical treatment, lost income, and long term rehabilitation.
Construction worker suffered multiple injuries due to unsafe job site conditions. Recovery included a substantial settlement and workers' compensation lien reduction.
Family of a working man killed in a truck accident secured compensation for financial losses, funeral expenses, and loss of companionship.
Client suffered serious injuries while staying at a hotel due to unsafe property conditions. Settlement covered medical care and future damages.
Worker injured while performing duties in the underground tunnel system at O'Hare Airport. Recovery covered lost wages and ongoing medical treatment.
Truck driver suffered a torn rotator cuff after a serious fall. Recovery included compensation for surgery, rehabilitation, and lost income.
Some case results are subject to confidentiality agreements. Past results do not guarantee future outcomes. Every case is unique and must be evaluated on its own facts and circumstances.
You Pay $0 Unless We Win Your Case.
We work on a contingency-fee basis. That means we cover all upfront costs, including investigators, expert witnesses, filing fees, the works. You only pay if and when we recover money for you. No win, no fee. No risk.
Why Injury Victims Choose Mulholland
Picking a personal injury lawyer is one of the most important decisions you'll make after an accident. Here's why hundreds of Sheboygan families have trusted us with theirs.
25+ Years of Experience
Since 2000, attorney Toby P. Mulholland has built a career on getting injury victims paid. Insurance companies know our name and our results.
Aggressive Representation
We don't take lowball offers. We don't roll over for adjusters. We negotiate hard and take cases to trial when insurance won't pay full value.
No Fee Unless We Win
Zero risk. Zero upfront cost. If we don't recover money for you, you don't pay us a dime. It's that simple.
You Talk To Your Attorney
You'll never be passed off to a paralegal. Toby personally handles every case from first call to final check. You'll have his cell number.
How We Force Insurance Companies To Pay Full Value
Insurance adjusters have one job: pay you as little as possible. They'll call within days, sound friendly, and offer a quick settlement before you understand what your case is really worth. Here's exactly how we counter their tactics:
We Build A Documented Case They Can't Dispute
Police reports, medical records, expert witnesses, accident reconstruction, we build a paper trail that makes lowballing impossible.
We Calculate The Full Value Of Your Damages
Future medical care, lost earning capacity, pain & suffering, loss of enjoyment of life. Every dollar you're entitled to.
We Handle Every Conversation With The Insurer
You never have to talk to an adjuster again. Everything goes through us so they can't trick you into hurting your own claim.
We Go To Trial When They Won't Pay Fair
Insurance companies know which lawyers settle for pennies and which actually try cases. We have a courtroom reputation that gets settlements moved.
Our 4-Step Process: From Phone Call To Payment
You focus on healing. We handle the legal fight. Here's exactly what happens after you reach out.
Free Consultation
Call or fill out the form. We respond within one business hour, 24/7. No obligation, no cost.
We Investigate
We gather evidence, talk to witnesses, request medical records, and value your claim at no cost to you.
We Demand Full Compensation
We negotiate aggressively with the insurance company. If they won't pay fair, we file suit and take it to trial.
You Get Paid
Once we recover money, you get paid. Our fee comes from the recovery. If we don't win, you owe nothing.
Type Of Injury Case We Handle In Sheboygan
We focus exclusively on personal injury. No estate planning, no divorce, and no business law. Just fighting for injury victims.
Car Accidents
Sheboygan sees its share of traffic accidents, from fender benders to catastrophic collisions. Our Sheboygan car accident attorneys specialize in helping victims of car accidents secure compensation for medical bills, lost wages, and pain and suffering. Whether the accident was caused by distracted driving, speeding, or reckless driving, we are here to hold the responsible parties accountable.
Truck Accidents
Accidents involving commercial trucks, such as semi-truck accidents and 18-wheeler accidents, are often much more complicated due to the involvement of large insurance companies and multiple at-fault parties. Our team knows how to investigate the cause of the accident, whether it was due to driver fatigue, faulty equipment, or improper cargo handling. We are committed to fighting for justice for victims involved in these types of accidents.
Medical Malpractice
When a medical professional makes a mistake, the consequences can be devastating. Whether it's a misdiagnosis, surgical error, or medication mistake, we work to ensure that you receive compensation for the harm caused by medical negligence. Our team has handled a wide variety of medical malpractice cases and understands the complexities involved.
Slip And Fall Accidents
Property owners have a responsibility to maintain safe premises. If you've been injured on someone else's property due to dangerous conditions, you may be entitled to compensation. Our Sheboygan slip and fall lawyers will help you understand your rights and ensure that those responsible for maintaining safe conditions are held accountable.
Wrongful Death Claims
Losing a loved one is an unimaginable tragedy, and when that loss is due to someone else's negligence, the pain can be even more profound. If you've lost a loved one due to an accident or injury caused by someone else's actions, you may be entitled to compensation for funeral costs, medical expenses, and loss of companionship. Our wrongful death attorneys in Sheboygan can guide you through this painful process and fight for the justice your family deserves.
Product Liability
If you've been injured by a defective product, whether it's a faulty car part, a dangerous consumer product, or a poorly designed medical device, our product liability lawyers in Sheboygan will work to hold the manufacturers and sellers accountable for their negligence.
Motorcycle Accident
Motorcyclists in Sheboygan face a higher risk of serious injury due to limited protection on the road. If you've been injured in a motorcycle crash caused by a negligent driver, poorly maintained road, or defective bike part, you may be entitled to significant compensation. Our Sheboygan motorcycle accident lawyers understand the unique challenges bikers face, from proving liability to overcoming bias. We fight aggressively to recover compensation for your medical costs, lost wages, long-term care, and pain and suffering.
Dog Bites
Dog attacks can leave victims, especially children, with severe physical and emotional trauma. In Wisconsin, dog owners are strictly liable for the injuries their pets cause. Whether the attack occurred in a public space or on private property, our Sheboygan dog bite lawyers can help you pursue justice. We work to secure damages for medical bills, scarring and disfigurement, psychological therapy, and lost income. Let us hold negligent pet owners accountable and protect your right to recover.
Pedestrian Accident
Sheboygan's streets and intersections can be dangerous for pedestrians, especially with the rise in distracted driving. If you were hit while crossing the street, walking along a road, or navigating a parking lot, our pedestrian accident attorneys are here to help. We thoroughly investigate the circumstances, handle insurance negotiations, and ensure you're not blamed for someone else's recklessness. Victims of pedestrian accidents often face catastrophic injuries, and we'll fight to make sure you're compensated fully and fairly.
Brain Injury Lawyer
Traumatic brain injuries can change a life forever. These cases require neurologists, life-care planners, and economists to value future damages properly. We've recovered millions for brain-injury victims and understand the complexities involved in proving the full extent of long-term cognitive and physical impairments.
Construction Accident Lawyer
Falls, equipment failures, and scaffolding collapses make construction sites dangerous. Third-party liability often opens up recovery beyond workers' comp. We pursue every angle to ensure injured construction workers receive the full compensation they deserve for their injuries and lost income.
Nursing Home Abuse Attorney
If a Sheboygan-area facility caused bedsores, malnutrition, unexplained injuries, or financial exploitation, we'll hold it accountable and recover damages. Our team fights to protect the rights of vulnerable elderly residents and their families.
Bicycle Accident Attorney
Cycling in Sheboygan offers a healthy, eco-friendly way to get around, but it also comes with risks. Bicyclists are among the most vulnerable road users, and when an accident occurs, the injuries can be life-altering. If you've been injured in a bicycle accident due to someone else's negligence, you may be entitled to compensation for your medical expenses, lost income, and pain and suffering.
Workers' Compensation Attorney
If you've been injured on the job, workers' compensation is meant to protect you by covering your medical expenses, lost wages, and rehabilitation costs. Unfortunately, getting the benefits you're entitled to isn't always easy. Insurance companies and even employers may dispute claims, reduce payouts, or deny benefits altogether.
5 Steps To Take Right Now To Protect Your Case
What you do in the first 24 hours after an injury matters more than almost anything else. Here's a quick checklist.
Get Medical Care
See a doctor immediately, even if you feel OK. Some injuries take days to show.
Document Everything
Photos of the scene, your injuries, the conditions, and any property damage.
File A Report
Police for vehicle accidents. Property owner/manager for slip & falls. Get it in writing.
Don't Settle Fast
Insurance will offer pennies. Once you sign, you can't reopen the case. Wait.
Call A Lawyer
Free consultation. We'll tell you honestly if you have a case. No obligation.
Wisconsin Gives You Only 3 Years, But Critical Evidence Disappears In Days
Surveillance footage gets overwritten. Witnesses forget. Vehicles get repaired. Insurance adjusters work fast to lock in low settlements. The sooner you have an attorney investigating your case, the stronger your claim becomes.
Get My Case Started Today →Answers To The Questions Every Injury Victim Asks
Get The Compensation You Deserve. Free Case Review In 60 Minutes.
You focus on healing. We'll handle the rest. Get a free, no-obligation case evaluation from a real attorney within one business hour.