If you’ve been injured on the job, workers’ compensation is meant to protect you, covering your medical
expenses, lost wages, and rehabilitation costs. Unfortunately, getting the benefits you’re entitled to isn’t always easy.
25+ years fighting insurance companies for injury victims
Downtown Milwaukee office at 790 N. Milwaukee Street, Suite 300
$0 out of pocket. You pay nothing unless we win your case
It's been great working with Toby. He's an excellent attorney that helped immensely during this difficult and stressful period. I especially appreciate open honest dialogue which he always provides.
I was in a life-threatening car accident in April of 2023 caused by a drunk driver. I was given Toby Mulholland's information through my insurance agent, and contacting him was the BEST decision I could have possibly made. Let me just say, Toby was my advocate every step of the way - in the midst of such a traumatic accident, I had comfort knowing my Lawyer was doing everything in his power to right the wrongs of the person who nearly took my life. Everything about that experience was new to me - I had never been in an accident, dealt with insurance, filed a suit, given a deposition, etc. Toby was informative regarding all the legal processes which were taking place, and answered all questions I had - in essence: he was my biggest advocate other than myself. He is extremely organized, well spoken, and knows exactly what he is talking about. Without his help, I don't know how I would have gotten through such a turbulent time. If you find yourself in a similar position to me, where it feels like your world is collapsing, medical facilities trying to push you around, insurance companies calling you... Toby Mulholland is the person you need to shield you from the noise, the advocate you deserve, and the best Lawyer around. Thank you for everything you have done to help me in my most dire of times, Toby!
Thank You for being more than attorney and seeing My situation for more than a payout if You're looking for a Lawyer that's gonna use the law to get You what You deserve and not be bought out by big corporations make sure You give Toby a call
I have been dealing with this law firm & Mr. Toby for a while now & have brought some friends to them, everyone left satisfied, and the relationship became more than just a client but a friendship, he works with passion, explains all the steps to you & guides you to the best, five stars ⭐️
Very responsible and caring team. I recommend Mulholland law to anyone in search of a great attorney. Toby was great! he is so down to earth and easy to reach. He clarified any doubt I had and explained the whole process step by step. Thank you so much for all you've done for me and my family. I am forever grateful!
Since launching his law practice in 2000, Toby P. Mulholland has been a dedicated advocate for clients
suffering serious injuries. He has extensive experience handling a wide range of personal injury cases,
including motor vehicle accidents, wrongful death claims, construction accidents, premises liability,
dog bite cases, and catastrophic injury litigation.
Toby’s distinguished career is marked by his skill in litigation, participating in numerous trials,
mediations, arbitrations, and depositions. His innovative approaches to depositions have consistently
resulted in successful outcomes for even the most complex cases. Clients appreciate his ability to
navigate high-stakes situations with a creative, results-oriented approach.
Licensing and Professional Associations
Licensed to practice law in Illinois, Arizona, and Wisconsin
Insurance companies and even employers may dispute claims, reduce payouts, or deny benefits altogether.
A dedicated Wisconsin workers’ compensation attorney can step in to level the playing field, fight for your rights, and make sure your claim is handled properly from the start.
Work injuries are common in Wisconsin. The latest federal counts show the state’s private employers report injuries at a higher rate than employers nationwide.
Wisconsin work injuries, 2024
109
Work-Related Deaths Wisconsin recorded 109 fatal work injuries. Transportation incidents caused 30 of them, and falls, slips, and trips caused 22.
57,500
Nonfatal Injuries and Illnesses Private employers in Wisconsin reported 57,500 workplace injuries and illnesses.
2.9
Wisconsin’s Injury Rate Cases per 100 full-time workers in Wisconsin, compared with 2.3 nationwide.
15,400
Manufacturing Injuries Cases reported by Wisconsin manufacturers, a rate of 3.4 per 100 full-time workers.
Wisconsin law requires most employers to carry workers’ compensation insurance. This coverage provides benefits to employees injured in the course of their work, regardless of fault.
Key benefits may include:
Benefit
What it covers
Wisconsin rule for 2026 injuries
Medical expenses
Hospital bills, surgery costs, prescriptions, and ongoing care.
Reasonable and necessary treatment is paid by the insurer, along with mileage to appointments.
Temporary disability benefits
A percentage of your lost wages while you recover.
Two-thirds of your average weekly wage, up to $1,375 a week, after a 3-day waiting period.
Permanent disability benefits
Compensation for lasting impairments.
A set number of weeks for each body part, at up to $446 a week, paid monthly.
Vocational rehabilitation
Assistance in returning to work or retraining for a new position.
Provided through the state Division of Vocational Rehabilitation, or paid by the insurer to a private provider when DVR can’t help.
Death benefits
Financial support for dependents of a worker who dies due to a job-related injury or illness.
Workplace injuries can happen in any industry, from construction and manufacturing to healthcare and office environments. Understanding the most common causes can help workers stay alert and employers create safer conditions. Some frequent causes include:
Slip, Trip, and Fall Accidents
Wet floors, uneven surfaces, or poorly lit areas can cause sudden falls that lead to serious injuries.
Milwaukee winters add ice to the list
48.7 inches of snow falls in Milwaukee in a normal year.
33,597 Wisconsin comp claims from 2000 to 2022 were for slips, trips, and falls on ice or snow between October and April.
2 to 3 days after an icy day, state researchers found slips can spike, because surfaces no longer look slippery.
Contact with toxic chemicals, dust, or fumes can cause respiratory issues, skin conditions, or long-term illnesses.
Workplace Violence
Physical altercations or assaults between employees or with third parties can also lead to injuries.
If you’ve been hurt on the job, whether from a sudden accident or a condition that developed over time, you have the right to pursue workers’ compensation benefits to cover your medical expenses and lost wages.
Common Workplace Injuries in Wisconsin
Workplace injuries can occur in any setting, from construction sites to offices. Common injuries include:
Back and neck injuries from heavy lifting or repetitive strain
Fractures and broken bones from falls or equipment accidents
Head and brain injuries caused by falling objects or slips
Burns and chemical exposure
Carpal tunnel syndrome and other repetitive motion injuries
Even valid claims can be denied. Common reasons include:
Disputes over whether the injury is work-related
A disputed claim needs medical proof: a written opinion from your physician, chiropractor, psychologist, podiatrist, or surgeon that ties the injury to your work. A dentist, physician assistant, or nurse prescriber can’t give that opinion.
Missing claim deadlines
Tell your supervisor right away. An injury that isn’t reported to your employer within two years generally can’t be claimed at all.
Incomplete or inaccurate paperwork
Comp payments are based on your practitioner’s reports. If those reports don’t reach the insurer promptly and regularly, your checks can be delayed.
Employer or insurer alleging misconduct or intoxication
If an injury was caused by drug or alcohol use, the insurer may owe only medical bills. Breaking a written safety rule that your employer enforces can cut benefits by 15%, up to $15,000.
The insurer must tell you within 14 days if it is still investigating your claim, and within 7 days after it decides to deny it, along with your right to a hearing. DWD worker’s comp guide
An experienced attorney ensures all requirements are met and fights back against unfair denials.
Where a Disputed Claim Goes in Milwaukee
Since January 1, 2026, workers’ comp disputes are decided by the state Department of Workforce Development (DWD) instead of the Division of Hearings and Appeals. DWD’s Worker’s Compensation Division has a Milwaukee office less than a mile west of ours.
DWD Worker’s Compensation Division, Milwaukee office819 N. Sixth St., Room 723, Milwaukee, WI 53203Division phone: (608) 266-1340DWD Insurance Letter 548
Report the injury
Tell your supervisor. Your employer reports it to its insurer, and you do not have to file a claim yourself.
The insurer pays or explains
The first check usually arrives within 14 days of your last day worked. If the insurer is still investigating, it must tell you within 14 days of learning about the injury.
Hearing before a judge
If the dispute can’t be settled, you apply to DWD for a hearing before an administrative law judge, with a written medical opinion supporting your claim.
Commission review
To challenge the judge’s decision, a petition must reach the Labor and Industry Review Commission within 21 days after the decision was mailed. A postmark is not enough.
Circuit court
A commission decision can be taken to circuit court within 30 days. The person appealing files in the county where they live, so Milwaukee County residents file in Milwaukee County Circuit Court.
Settling instead: Many disputes end in a compromise settlement. Every compromise must be approved by the Worker’s Compensation Division, and once you sign, it is very hard to change, so understand what future benefits you are giving up first.
How a Wisconsin Workers’ Compensation Attorney Can Help?
When you hire a workers’ compensation lawyer, you gain an advocate who will:
Gather medical evidence and expert testimony
File your claim correctly and on time
Negotiate with the insurance company for fair benefits
Represent you in hearings or appeals if needed
Protect you from employer retaliation
What a comp lawyer costs in Wisconsin
In a disputed claim, Wisconsin limits the attorney’s fee to 20% of the compensation the attorney obtains for you, plus costs. The fee and costs are deducted from your payments, so nothing is paid up front.
In Wisconsin, you must report your injury to your employer as soon as possible, ideally within 30 days. Claims must typically be filed within two years of the injury. If the injury is reported or a payment is made within two years, the claim usually stays open for 6 years from the injury or the last payment, whichever is later. Missing these deadlines can result in losing your right to benefits.
30 days
Tell your employer
Wisconsin expects notice within 30 days of the injury, or of when you knew it was related to your work.
2 years
Report or lose it
An injury not reported to your employer within two years generally can’t be claimed.
3 years
Sue a third party
An injury lawsuit against someone other than your employer, like a driver, generally must be filed within 3 years.
6 years
Claim stays open
From the injury or the last payment, whichever is later, once the injury was reported or paid.
No limit
Occupational disease
Hearing loss and carpal tunnel have no filing limit. Neither do some serious injuries, like loss of a hand or arm, vision loss, permanent brain injury, or a hip or knee replacement.
Most comp claims run between you, your employer and its insurer. These four situations change what you can recover.
Someone else caused the injury
Workers’ comp is generally your only remedy against your own employer, and it does not pay for pain and suffering. If a negligent driver, equipment maker, or contractor caused the injury, you may also sue them. After attorney fees and costs, you keep one-third of that recovery, the comp insurer is repaid, and the rest goes to you as a credit against future comp.
Wisconsin’s Uninsured Employers Fund pays benefits as if the employer had been insured, then collects from the employer. The claim starts with a UEF claim application to DWD, backed by records of your job, your injury and your treatment.
If your injury was caused by your employer not following a state or federal safety provision, the employer must pay 15% more in compensation, up to $15,000. It is owed even if your own carelessness played a part.
The law doesn’t guarantee your job, but an employer that unreasonably refuses to rehire you when suitable work is available can owe up to one year’s wages. If you can’t return to your old work, ask the insurer about vocational rehabilitation.
Straight answers for Milwaukee workers hurt on the job.
Do I have to prove my employer was at fault?
No. Workers’ compensation is a no-fault system, meaning you can receive benefits even if the accident was your own error.
Can I see my own doctor?
Yes, Wisconsin allows you to choose your own treating physician. You can pick any physician, chiropractor, psychologist, podiatrist, dentist, physician assistant, or advanced practice nurse prescriber licensed in Wisconsin. If you later switch to a second one, notify your employer or its insurer. The insurer can still have you examined by a practitioner it chooses.
What if my employer doesn’t have workers’ comp insurance?
You may still be able to claim benefits through the Wisconsin Uninsured Employers Fund. The fund pays benefits as if your employer had been insured and then seeks repayment from the employer.
Can I be fired for filing a workers’ compensation claim?
No. It is illegal for employers to retaliate against employees for seeking benefits. An employer that refuses to rehire an injured worker without reasonable cause, when suitable work is available, can owe up to one year of lost wages.
How much does Wisconsin workers’ comp pay in 2026?
While you are healing, comp pays two-thirds of your average weekly wage, up to $1,375 a week for injuries in 2026. Permanent disability is paid at up to $446 a week, and the maximum death benefit is $412,500, plus up to $10,000 for burial.
Do I have to file the claim myself?
Not if you reported the injury. Your employer reports it to its insurer, which reports it to the state Worker’s Compensation Division when required. You only need to apply for a hearing if benefits are denied or stop and the dispute can’t be settled.
When will I get my first check?
Usually within 14 days of your last day worked. Wage benefits start after a 3-day waiting period, and those first 3 days are paid too if you miss work beyond the 7th calendar day after the injury.
Who decides a disputed workers’ comp claim in Milwaukee?
Since January 1, 2026, an administrative law judge with DWD’s Worker’s Compensation Division, which has a Milwaukee office at 819 N. Sixth St., Room 723. A petition for review by the Labor and Industry Review Commission must be received within 21 days after the judge’s decision is mailed, and a commission decision can be appealed to circuit court within 30 days.
How much does a workers’ comp lawyer cost in Wisconsin?
In a disputed claim, the attorney’s fee is limited to 20% of the compensation the attorney obtains for you, plus costs, and it is deducted from your payments. You pay nothing up front.
Should I sign a compromise settlement?
Only once you understand what future benefits you are giving up. Every compromise must be approved by the Worker’s Compensation Division, and after you agree to one it is legally very difficult to change.
I was hurt in a car crash while working. Can I sue the other driver?
Usually, yes. You can collect workers’ comp and also bring an injury claim against the driver who caused the crash, generally within 3 years. Part of what you recover from the driver repays the comp insurer, but you keep at least one-third after attorney fees and costs.
Is carpal tunnel syndrome covered by workers’ comp?
Yes. Carpal tunnel syndrome caused by your work is treated as an occupational disease, and Wisconsin sets no time limit for filing an occupational disease claim.
Speak With a Wisconsin Workers’ Compensation Attorney Today
If you’ve been hurt at work, don’t let delays, denials, or intimidation stop you from getting the benefits you deserve. Our Wisconsin workers’ compensation attorneys are ready to protect your rights, handle the paperwork, and fight for maximum compensation.
Summarized from the Wisconsin Statutes, the Wisconsin Department of Workforce Development, the Labor and Industry Review Commission, the Wisconsin Department of Health Services, the National Weather Service and the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics as of October 2026. This is general information, not legal advice. Benefit amounts change each year and deadlines have exceptions, so talk to a lawyer about your situation.